Current:Home > NewsAll major social media platforms fail LGBTQ+ people — but Twitter is the worst, says GLAAD-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
All major social media platforms fail LGBTQ+ people — but Twitter is the worst, says GLAAD
View Date:2024-12-24 22:15:04
GLAAD, the world's largest LGBTQ+ media advocacy organization, announced on Thursday that its third annual Social Media Safety Index found that all five major social media platforms — Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube and Twitter — received low or failing scores on its platform scorecard for the second year in a row — with Twitter receiving the lowest grade in its ability to protect LGBTQ+ users.
"These platforms continue to fail at enforcing the safeguarding of LGBTQ users from online hate speech, fail at providing transparency in the use of LGBTQ-specific user data and fail in expressing commitments to protecting LGBTQ users," the organization wrote on Twitter.
In particular, transgender, non-binary and gender non-conforming users are subject to hate speech and harassment on social media, the report found.
According to GLAAD, "the SMSI Platform Scorecard offers an evaluation of LGBTQ safety, privacy, and expression on five major platforms...based on 12 LGBTQ-specific indicators," which include the ability for users to add pronouns to their bios, public disclosure that a platform does not recommend content to a user based on their inferred gender identity or sexual orientation without their explicit consent and internal corporate structures to actualize the protection of LGBTQ users from harm.
Twitter received only a 33% score this year, down 12 points since Elon Musk took over the platform in 2022, while all other platforms improved their score from the previous year. By contrast, Instagram scored 63%, Instagram 61%, TikTok 57% and YouTube 54% score on the 2023 report.
The SMSI identified issues of inadequate content moderation and enforcement across the board, "harmful" algorithms, and a general "lack of transparency and accountability across the industry, among many other issues — all of which disproportionately impact LGBTQ users and other marginalized communities who are uniquely vulnerable to hate, harassment, and discrimination."
"Dehumanizing anti-LGBTQ content on social media such as misinformation and hate have an outsized impact on real world violence and harmful anti-LGBTQ legislation, but social media platforms too often fail at enforcing their own policies regarding such content," said GLAAD President and CEO Sarah-Kate Ellis.
Additional key findings in the 2023 SMSI include anti-LGBTQ+ online rhetoric leading to harm in offline life, anti-LGBTQ+ hate speech is "an alarming public health and safety issue" and platforms across the board are guilty of a lack of transparency in how they report. Platforms were also found to disproportionately suppress LGBTQ+-centered content through demonitization and content removal.
The SMSI includes "key recommendations" for each of the platforms to improve the climate for LBGTQ+ users.
On Twitter, attacks on LGBTQ+ users have increased substantially since Musk took over, according to a combined report by Media Matters and GLAAD. The report found that retweets of posts from anti-LGBTQ+ accounts that contained "groomer" rhetoric increased over 1200% since Musk's purchase of Twitter.
In April, Twitter removed a policy against the "targeted misgendering or deadnaming of transgender individuals."
"We want our products and platforms to be safe for everyone. We engage with civil society organizations around the world in our work to design policies and create tools that foster a safe online environment," a Meta spokesperson told CBS News.
"This approach is always evolving, and input from LGBTQ+ safety and advocacy organizations is critical to informing and continually improving Meta's technologies and programs."
TikTok said they were "always looking to strengthen our approach" with the help of their users and experts such as GLAAD.
"At TikTok, we're focused on building a safe and supportive platform where the LGBTQ+ community can keep inspiring and thriving," said a statement from a company spokesperson. "We're proud to have strong policies aimed at protecting LGBTQ+ individuals from harassment and hate speech, including misgendering and deadnaming."
A YouTube spokesperson told CBS News that its policies "prohibit content that promotes violence or hatred against members of the LGBTQ+ community."
"Over the last few years, we've made significant progress in our ability to quickly remove this content from our platform and prominently surface authoritative sources in search results and recommendations. We remain committed to this important work, and we appreciate the thoughtful feedback from GLAAD."
Twitter's press email auto-replied with a poop emoji — as has been custom for months since Musk let go of the members of Twitter's public relations team.
- In:
- Elon Musk
- Social Media
- Meta
- LGBTQ+
- TikTok
- YouTube
C Mandler is a social media producer and trending topics writer for CBS News, focusing on American politics and LGBTQ+ issues.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Shel Talmy, produced hits by The Who, The Kinks and other 1960s British bands, dead at 87
- Breaking Down the Wild B-Girl Raygun Conspiracy Theories After Her Viral 2024 Olympics Performance
- More than 2,300 pounds of meth is found hidden in celery at Georgia farmers market
- Warheads flavored Cinnabon rolls and drinks set to make debut this month: Get the details
- Florida Man Arrested for Cold Case Double Murder Almost 50 Years Later
- August 2024's full moon is a rare super blue moon: When to see it
- Mark Wahlberg's Kids Are All Grown Up in First Red Carpet Appearance in 9 Years
- Indiana attorney general drops suit over privacy of Ohio girl who traveled for abortion
- Kalen DeBoer, Jalen Milroe save Alabama football season, as LSU's Brian Kelly goes splat
- What Exes Julianne Hough and Ryan Seacrest Have Said About Their Relationship
Ranking
- Alexandra Daddario Shares Candid Photo of Her Postpartum Body 6 Days After Giving Birth
- Maui judge’s ruling bars insurers from going after defendants who agreed to $4B wildfire settlement
- DNA investigation links California serial killer to 1986 killing of young woman near Los Angeles
- Pro-Trump lawyer removed from Dominion case after leaking documents to cast doubt on 2020 election
- NFL overreactions: New York Jets, Dallas Cowboys going nowhere after Week 10
- Houston’s former mayor is the Democrats’ nominee to succeed the late US Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee
- WHO declares mpox outbreaks in Africa a global health emergency as a new form of the virus spreads
- USA Basketball's Grant Hill has rough edges to smooth before 2028 Olympics
Recommendation
-
How Saturday Night Live Reacted to Donald Trump’s Win Over Kamala Harris
-
Jorō spiders, the mysterious arachnids invading the US, freeze when stressed, study shows
-
Paris gymnastics scoring saga and the fate of Jordan Chiles' bronze medal: What we know
-
Back-to-school-shopping 2024: See which 17 states offer sales-tax holidays
-
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign chancellor to step down at end of academic year
-
Where Kyle Richards Really Stands With RHOBH Costars After Season 13 Breakup Drama
-
US safety agency ends probe of Tesla suspension failures without seeking a recall
-
How Amal and George Clooney Are Protecting Their 2 Kids From the Spotlight